The correct answers are must have been, didn't have to investigate, and would bring.
Let's look at Bob's original, direct speech and how the modals backshift (or don't) in reported speech:
- "I must have been at my desk." (Past deduction). Modals of past deduction (must have + past participle) do not change in reported speech. "Had to be" would incorrectly imply an obligation, not a deduction.
- "You needn't investigate further." (Present lack of obligation). When reporting a lack of obligation, needn't backshifts to didn't have to (or wouldn't have to for the future). "Needn't have investigated" would mean we did investigate but it was unnecessary, which changes the meaning.
- "I will bring a new box." (Future promise). The modal will simply backshifts to would.
Indirect speech
Direct vs indirect speech: direct speech quotes exact words (She said, "I am tired."). Indirect speech reports the meaning (She said she was tired.). The key difference is backshift — tenses move one step into the past when the reporting verb is past tense.
Indirect speech = reported words without quotation marks. Core mechanism: backshift (present→past, past→past perfect, will→would) + pronoun/time shifts.
Diagnostic: is the reporting verb past (said, told)? → backshift required. Is it present (says, tells)? → no shift needed. Exception: universal truths don't shift (He said the Earth is round).
Modal verb
Must vs should vs might: the most confused modal trio. Must = strong obligation/near-certainty. Should = advice/expectation. Might = possibility. Getting these wrong changes the force of your statement: You must see a doctor (urgent) vs You should see a doctor (advice) vs You might need a doctor (maybe).
Modal verbs are auxiliaries that encode modality: ability (can), permission (may), necessity (must), advice (should), possibility (might), future (will).
Diagnostic: what meaning are you adding? Obligation → must/have to. Advice → should. Possibility → might/could. Ability → can. Future → will.
Verb
Verb vs noun vs adjective: nouns name things. Adjectives describe. Verbs express what happens or what IS. The test: can it take tense (walked, will walk)? Can it take -ing? Can it follow to as an infinitive (to walk)? Yes to any → verb. English often converts freely between classes (run = noun or verb), so context decides.
A verb = action/state/occurrence word. 5 forms (base, -s, past, past participle, -ing). Carries tense, aspect, mood, voice. The one required element in every sentence.
Diagnostic: does it change for tense (walk → walked)? Can you put to before it (to walk)? Does it take -ing (walking)? → verb.
C1 | Advanced
C1 vs C2: C1 means fluent and flexible use with occasional gaps in very unfamiliar domains. C2 means native-like command of idiom, irony, and register across any subject. If you can handle advanced grammar but still miss cultural nuance or very rare idioms, you're C1.
C1 is the advanced CEFR level: inversion, cleft sentences, subjunctive mood, advanced conditionals, and precise register control in professional and academic contexts.
Diagnostic: can you write persuasively in different registers and catch subtle irony? Consistently → C2. Sometimes → C1.
Hard
Hard vs Medium: Medium tests one rule with realistic distractors. Hard tests interacting rules, edge cases, or context-dependent answers where multiple options seem correct until you think deeply. If you're scoring 80%+ on Medium, try Hard to find your real gaps.
The Hard tag filters for B2+ challenges with layered difficulty: rule interactions, subtle distractors, and contexts that demand genuine grammatical reasoning.
Diagnostic: if Hard questions feel impossible, drop to Medium and master the individual rules first. Hard assumes you already know each rule — it tests whether you can apply them together.